Taking your Extreme Definition two-tone eye definer in “Trend Setter” ($7, at drugstores), lightly line your lower waterline all the way across. If it’s tricky to get up there with the pencil, transferring the makeup is an easy way to cover everything. To do this, blink your eyes hard to transfer some eyeliner to the top lashline. Using a tiny brush, layer a black eyeshadow over this liner to ensure that it stays. Kate’s eyeliner always stays put!