Fashion

Canadian retailer Jacob “takes a stand” on retouching

9 comments

Jacob announced this afternoon that as of their current campaign, they will no longer be altering the bodies of the models who appear in ads for both their clothing and lingerie brands. A press release from the Quebec-based retailer says they have decided to “take a stand” on retouching, stating:

“As a socially responsible company, JACOB has always made an effort to promote a healthy image of the female body. By adopting an official policy and broadcasting it publicly, we hope to reverse the trend in digital photo manipulation that has become excessive in our industry,” says spokesperson and Communications Director Cristelle Basmaji. “Our decision to never reshape the bodies of our models is particularly innovative for our JACOB Lingerie campaigns.”

Included with the release were three images–what Jacob says is the original shot, the image used in the campaign, and the same picture retouched as it would have been before the new policy. We are hard pressed to see a major difference between the first two, though the third–showing thinning in the hips and thighs and shading on the model’s bust–suggests that the company wasn’t engaging in anything nearly as extreme as the infamously stretched Ralph Lauren ad starring Filippa Hamilton. (Critics of this kind of photo manipulation would argue that extreme or not, any is too much.) Jacob is careful to stipulate that they are not against all retouching: The company will still erase uneven skin tone or scars and will correct colours.

Retouching has become a hot-button issue. Recent controversies surrounding Photoshop work on images on Nordstrom’s and Ann Taylor’s websites forced both companies to admit that they’d been a bit “heavy-handed” and “overzealous,” respectively, but Jacob is one of the first major clothing brands we know of to institute a near ban on manipulating the bodies of the models in their images. It will be interesting to see any brands in Canada or the U.S. follow suit.

What do you think? Do you want to see more companies do this? Tell us in the comments!

Click the images below to see larger versions of the images

Join the discussion

  • bob f

    yes it has to change it is getting so that humans (especially women) have a false ideal of what is true and beautiful…it has to STOP now…

  • Liz

    *their

  • http://www.lukasdp.com lukas peters

    I feel it resides within the industry to decide on manipulative limitations and not on outside pressure groups demanding ‘real beauty’. Fashion imagery is not selling the model, they are selling what the model is wearing – and if in the retouching process it is possible to remove elements from the models figure that potentially distract from the clothing then I see no issue in granting the industry free reign to do so. Photography is reality re-renderd onto two dimensional space making it a falsehood from the moment of capture. I dont think anyone looks to fashion magazines for a true representation of what is natural, and no one seems to have issue with the hollywood blockbusters portraying their starlets through vastly manipulative post-production methods so why the still image is subject to so much ridicule I don’t know.
    ~lukas.
    lukasdp.com

  • Kayla

    I think this is a great campaign idea and i am very excited to see which retailers follow !!

  • edel

    Good for them but with the no-retouching policy comes the issue that they’ve cut out thier large sizes. I used to shop at Jacob all the time, it was my favourite store, but with the re-launch of their brand this spring (or sometimes around there) they cut out the XL size (which wasn’t anything over a standard size 12) and only have xs, s, m and l – which the large sells out almost on the first day. so for anyone over a size 10 its impossible to shop there now, this includes me. So maybe they don’t retouch their photos, but their clothes no longer cater to the 24-35 demographic of women’s changing bodies. In my opinion. Or maybe I should just work out harder to get my boby back to post baby… it’s kind of a double standard I find.

  • Pingback: fashion news « the design

  • Pingback: Retouching images for fashion | dannyt1

  • Pingback: My Reasearch For Research Project « Stephany Ferreira Creative Histories

  • Pingback: My Reasearch For Research Project « Stephany Ferreira Creative Histories

Neither the author nor FASHION Magazine necessarily agrees with the comments posted here. Editors will not correct spelling or grammar. FASHION Magazine reserves the right to edit or delete comments entirely.

Your Friends’ Favourites

Join Fashion
Advertisement
Advertisement